Arizona Supreme Court Clarifies Right to Remain Silent

Yellow legal pad on a courtroom desk with typed Miranda warning text reading ‘You have the right to remain silent. Anything you say can and will be used AGAINST YOU,’ next to a gavel and pen.

What does it really mean to remain silent? In State v. Melendez, the Arizona Supreme Court ruled that vague or hesitant answers aren’t enough—you must clearly invoke your right to silence, or risk giving the prosecution ammunition. Here’s what happened, why it matters, and how to protect yourself.

Eyewitness Testimony: Importance and Limits in Criminal Cases

Understanding the Importance and Limitations of Eyewitness Testimony in Criminal Cases

What does it mean to truly invoke your right to remain silent? In State v. Melendez, the Arizona Supreme Court held that unclear or hesitant responses don’t count—you must speak up clearly, or the prosecution may use your words against you. Here’s why that matters and how to stay protected.

Should I hire a lawyer instead of keeping my public defender?

Should I hire a lawyer instead of keeping my public defender

What does it truly mean to stay silent? In the State v. Melendez case, Arizona’s highest court decided that unclear or unsure statements don’t count—you have to clearly state your right to remain silent, or it could be used by the prosecution. Here’s what you need to know to protect yourself.

I’m Innocent! Why Do I Still Need a Lawyer?

You need a lawyer even if you are innocent because you cannot defend yourself the way a lawyer will

What does it take to properly remain silent? In State v. Melendez, the Arizona Supreme Court ruled that hesitation or vague replies aren’t enough—you must clearly assert your right, or risk giving the prosecution an advantage. Find out what happened and how to protect your rights.