A Tucson family says they feel monitored after a neighbor installed cameras pointed at their home. Attorney Joel Chorny shares his legal perspective in this exclusive interview.
Frequently Asked Questions.
Facing criminal charges can feel overwhelming. These answers provide general information about criminal cases in Tucson and Arizona, including what happens after an arrest, when to contact a lawyer, court appearances, possible case outcomes, and criminal record sealing.
What should I do if I’ve been arrested in Tucson, Arizona?
If you are arrested, remain calm and avoid discussing the facts of the case with police, other people in custody, or anyone else until you have spoken with an attorney. You have the right to remain silent and the right to legal counsel.
In Arizona, a person who is arrested must generally be brought before a judge for an initial appearance within 24 hours or be released. At that hearing, the court explains the charges and addresses release conditions. Contacting a criminal defense attorney as early as possible can help you understand your rights, the allegations, and what steps may come next.
When should I hire a criminal defense attorney?
It is generally best to speak with a criminal defense attorney as early as possible if you have been arrested, charged with a crime, contacted by investigators, served with a summons, or believe you may be under investigation.
Early legal advice can help you understand what to say, what not to say, what deadlines or court dates may apply, and what evidence may need to be preserved. You do not necessarily have to wait until formal charges are filed before consulting an attorney.
What happens at a first appearance in Arizona?
The first court appearance in an Arizona criminal case is commonly called the initial appearance. The judge will generally confirm your identity, inform you of the charges, advise you of important rights, and address whether an attorney should be appointed if you cannot afford one.
The judge may also determine whether probable cause exists for purposes of continued custody and set release conditions, such as release on your own recognizance, a bond, or other restrictions. The initial appearance is not the trial and does not determine whether you are guilty or not guilty.
What is the difference between a public defender and a private criminal defense attorney?
A public defender is a licensed criminal defense attorney appointed by the court for a person who qualifies financially and whose case is eligible for appointed counsel. In Pima County, the court may appoint the Public Defender, Legal Defender, Legal Advocate, or another court-appointed attorney depending on the case and any potential conflicts.
A private criminal defense attorney is hired directly by the defendant. The attorney-client relationship begins through a private agreement rather than a court appointment. The right choice depends on your circumstances, financial eligibility, the type of case, and the legal representation available to you.
How much does a criminal defense lawyer cost in Tucson?
Criminal defense fees vary depending on the type and seriousness of the charge, the amount of investigation required, whether expert witnesses or extensive motions are needed, and whether the case is resolved through negotiation or proceeds toward trial.
Some attorneys use flat fees for certain matters, while others may structure fees differently depending on the case. The most reliable way to understand the potential cost is to discuss the specific facts and charges during a consultation.
Can criminal charges be reduced or dismissed in Arizona?
In some cases, charges may be reduced, amended, or dismissed, but no particular outcome can be guaranteed. The result depends on the evidence, the applicable law, the prosecution's position, procedural issues, available defenses, and the facts of the individual case.
A defense attorney may review issues such as the legality of a stop or search, witness credibility, available video or physical evidence, testing procedures, constitutional violations, and whether the prosecution can prove each required element of the charge.
Will my criminal case go to trial?
Not every criminal case goes to trial. Some cases are dismissed, some are resolved through negotiated agreements, and others proceed to trial when the parties cannot reach a resolution or when the defendant chooses to contest the charges at trial.
Whether trial is appropriate depends on the evidence, the available defenses, potential sentencing exposure, the prosecution's offer, and the defendant's goals. Your attorney should explain the available options so you can make an informed decision.
How long does a criminal case usually take in Arizona?
The length of a criminal case varies substantially. A relatively straightforward misdemeanor may move more quickly, while a serious felony involving extensive discovery, expert analysis, motions, or multiple hearings may take considerably longer.
The court's schedule, the complexity of the evidence, plea negotiations, motions, witness availability, and whether the case proceeds to trial can all affect the timeline. An attorney familiar with the specific case can provide a more realistic estimate after reviewing the charges and procedural history.
What should I do if I’m falsely accused of a crime?
Avoid confronting the person making the accusation and avoid posting about the situation on social media. Preserve potentially useful information such as messages, emails, photographs, videos, receipts, location records, and the names of possible witnesses.
You should also be cautious about giving statements to investigators without first discussing the situation with an attorney. A defense attorney can evaluate the accusation, identify evidence that may support your position, and communicate with investigators or prosecutors when appropriate.
Can I seal or clear my criminal record in Arizona?
Arizona law allows some people to petition the court to seal criminal case records. Depending on the circumstances, eligible records may include certain convictions, dismissed charges, cases resulting in a not-guilty verdict, or arrests where charges were never filed.
Eligibility depends on several factors, including the offense, whether all sentence requirements have been completed, applicable waiting periods, and whether the offense is excluded from sealing under Arizona law. Record sealing is different from simply erasing a case, and sealed records can still be available for certain legally permitted purposes.
If you want to know whether a particular Arizona case may qualify, the specific charge, disposition, sentence, and date of completion should be reviewed individually.
This information is general in nature and is not legal advice. Criminal cases can vary significantly based on the facts, charges, court, and applicable Arizona law.
Police Say “Wait Here”—Are You Free to Leave?