Imagine you’re about to embark on a journey through unfamiliar territory. You have two guides to choose from. One offers a quick, free map and a few words of advice; the other sits down with you, studies your route, asks about your goals, and crafts a detailed plan, though there’s a fee for their time. This is the difference between free and paid consultations in criminal defense. Both have value, but understanding what each offers can make all the difference when your future is at stake.
A legal consultation is your first real step toward resolving a criminal charge. It’s a chance to meet an attorney, share your story, and understand your options. But not all consultations are created equal. Some are free, some come with a price tag, and the experience you receive can vary dramatically.
The Law Office of Joel Chorny, like many reputable Tucson firms, offers both types of consultations. The choice you make depends on your needs, the complexity of your case, and how much guidance you want right from the start.
Think of a free consultation as a friendly introduction. During this meeting, you’ll have the opportunity to explain your situation, ask basic questions about the legal process, and learn about the attorney’s experience. These sessions are usually brief—often 20 to 30 minutes—and focus on whether your case is a good fit for the firm.
Free consultations are especially helpful if you’re unsure whether you need a lawyer, are comparing several attorneys, or have a straightforward issue like a minor traffic violation. They lower the barrier to entry, letting you seek help without worrying about cost. A 2024 survey by the National Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers found that nearly 70% of people seeking legal help started with a free consultation.
But there are limits. Because these meetings are short and the attorney hasn’t been formally retained, you’re unlikely to receive detailed legal advice or in-depth strategy. Ethical rules prevent lawyers from giving specific recommendations unless they have all the facts and a formal agreement. This means that while you’ll leave with a better understanding of your situation, you may still have lingering questions about the best path forward.
A paid consultation is more like a full planning session with your guide. Here, the attorney devotes more time—often an hour or more—to reviewing your documents, analyzing the details of your case, and offering tailored advice. You’ll discuss possible defenses, risks, and next steps. The attorney may even spot issues or opportunities that would be missed in a shorter, free meeting.
For example, consider someone facing a DUI charge. In a paid consultation, the attorney might review the police report, examine breathalyzer calibration records, and explain how to challenge the evidence. They’ll outline a step-by-step plan and discuss what to expect at each stage of the process. This level of detail is rarely possible in a free session.
Paid consultations are particularly valuable for complex cases—felonies, allegations involving multiple parties, or situations where time is of the essence. The fee, which in Tucson usually ranges from $150 to $400, is an investment in clarity and preparedness. According to a 2025 Arizona Bar Association report, clients who paid for an initial consultation were 50% more likely to move forward with that attorney and reported higher satisfaction with the outcome.
Let’s look at a real-world scenario. Carlos, a Tucson resident, was arrested on suspicion of drug possession after a routine traffic stop. He first attended two free consultations with different attorneys. Each meeting lasted about 20 minutes. The lawyers listened to his story, explained the basic process, and quoted their fees. But Carlos left both meetings feeling uncertain. No one had reviewed the police report or discussed the specifics of his arrest.
Frustrated, Carlos decided to pay for a consultation with The Law Office of Joel Chorny. This time, the experience was different. The attorney spent over an hour with Carlos, carefully reviewing the police report and bodycam footage. He noticed that the officers never asked for consent to search Carlos’s trunk—a crucial detail that violated Arizona’s search and seizure laws. The attorney explained how this could be the basis for a motion to suppress the evidence.
With this insight, Carlos hired the attorney. The motion was filed, and the judge agreed to exclude the evidence. The charges were dismissed, saving Carlos from a possible felony conviction and years of hardship. The $300 he spent on the consultation turned out to be the best investment he could have made.
Both free and paid consultations have their place. Free consultations are ideal for those who are just starting, want to meet several attorneys, or have simple cases. They’re a great way to get a feel for a lawyer’s personality and approach.
Paid consultations, on the other hand, are best for those who need immediate, concrete advice. They’re also crucial when your case involves serious charges, complex facts, or when you need to act quickly to preserve evidence or respond to a court deadline.
It’s important to remember that, regardless of the type, all consultations are confidential. Even if you don’t hire the attorney, what you discuss cannot be shared with anyone else.
To get the most out of any consultation, come prepared. Bring all relevant documents—police reports, court notices, emails, or any evidence you have. Write down your questions and concerns. Be honest about your situation, even if you’re embarrassed or afraid. The more information you provide, the better the attorney can assess your case.
If you choose a paid consultation, expect a more thorough review and direct advice. You may leave with a clear action plan and a better sense of your legal options.
Copyright © 2025 Law Office Of Joel Chorny | All rights reserved
Disclaimer: Contacting The Law Office of Joel Chorny does not create an attorney-client relationship. Confidentiality and conflict checks are required before engagement. For full details, please visit our Contact Us page.